Post: Hiring a Consultant Isn’t an FSVP: Lessons from FDA’s Latest Warning Letter

FSVP

Hiring a Consultant Isn’t an FSVP: Lessons from FDA’s Latest Warning Letter

By Dr. Maxime Ndayizeye
BQUALI LLC (Atlanta)

When FDA inspects a U.S. food importer, the question is not whether the company has hired a consultant. The question is whether the importer has developed, maintained, and followed a Foreign Supplier Verification Program for the foods it actually brings into the United States.

A warning letter FDA posted on November 17, 2026, makes that distinction plain. This article explains what the letter says, why a generic consultant SOP is not an FSVP, and what a real program must contain for each food and foreign supplier. It is an educational overview, not legal advice. Always read the current regulation and, where needed, consult qualified counsel for your operation.

What FDA found

According to FDA’s warning letter, dated October 9, 2026, and posted November 17, 2026, investigators conducted an FSVP inspection of a food importer in Santa Ana, California, from June 29 through July 14, 2026. The inspection was conducted under section 805 of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act and 21 CFR part 1, subpart L. At the end of the inspection, the investigator issued a Form FDA 483a, FSVP Observations.

The significant violation, as stated in the letter, was that the importer “did not develop, maintain, and follow an FSVP as required by section 805 of the FD&C Act and 21 CFR 1.502(a).” Specifically, the firm had not developed an FSVP for foods imported from a foreign supplier (the supplier’s name and location are redacted in the public letter), including but not limited to cinnamon, cassia, ground, cracked (spice); corn; and instant noodles.

The letter also describes a July 30, 2026 response from the firm’s consultant. According to FDA, the consultant said the firm had retained them to help develop and maintain an FSVP, and had stopped importing paste products, pasta, jam and jelly, instant coffee, and some produce. The response included a Foreign Supplier Verification Program Standard Operating Procedure, FSVPs for the discontinued products, a Service Agreement and appendix, and FDA forms. The firm signed the Service Agreement; the consultant did not. No FSVP documents were provided for the foods still under review. FDA wrote that it could not evaluate the response because supporting documentation of corrective actions had not been provided, and that no additional FSVP documents had been received as of the date of the letter.

The letter warns that FDA may refuse admission of the food or place foods from the identified foreign suppliers on detention without physical examination under Import Alert 99-41. Importing food without a required FSVP is a prohibited act under section 301(zz) of the FD&C Act.

Why a consultant SOP is not an FSVP

Hiring a consultant is not an FSVP. A consultant can be a qualified individual and can help write, implement, and maintain an FSVP. The rule allows that. Under 21 CFR 1.500, a qualified individual “may be, but is not required to be, an employee of the importer.” What the rule does not allow is substituting a retainer agreement, or a generic SOP, for the program itself.

21 CFR 1.502(a) requires the importer, for each food it imports, to develop, maintain, and follow an FSVP. FDA’s explanation of the final rule is more specific: if you obtain one food from several suppliers, you need a separate FSVP for each supplier. If you obtain many foods from one supplier, you need a separate FSVP for each food.

That is the gap in this letter. According to FDA, the firm submitted an SOP and FSVPs for products it had stopped importing, but not for the foods still under review. FDA also could not evaluate the response without records showing that corrective actions had actually been taken. The importer owns the FSVP. A consultant can help you build it, but a service agreement and a generic SOP are not a substitute for food- and supplier-specific work, and for the records that prove the program is being followed.

What a real FSVP contains for each food and supplier

Use this checklist against 21 CFR part 1, subpart L. A template that has not been completed for the foods and suppliers you actually use is not a program.

  • A written hazard analysis (21 CFR 1.504). Write one for each type of food you import, regardless of its outcome. Identify and evaluate known or reasonably foreseeable biological, chemical, and physical hazards. You may review an analysis prepared by another entity, including your foreign supplier, but you must document that review, including that a qualified individual conducted the analysis.
  • An evaluation of the food and the supplier, and documented approval (21 CFR 1.505). Before approving a foreign supplier, evaluate the risk posed by the food and that supplier’s performance, including the hazard analysis, who is significantly minimizing or preventing the hazards, the supplier’s food-safety procedures, relevant FDA compliance information, and the supplier’s food-safety history. Document the evaluation and the approval.
  • Written procedures and supplier verification activities (21 CFR 1.506). Establish written procedures so that you import only from approved foreign suppliers, and written procedures for verification activities. Before importing a food, determine and document which activities are appropriate, and how often, based on the § 1.505 evaluation. Appropriate activities include onsite audits, sampling and testing, review of the supplier’s relevant food-safety records, and other appropriate activities. Conduct and document those activities before importing and periodically thereafter. An annual onsite audit by a qualified auditor is generally expected when a hazard controlled by the foreign supplier could reasonably result in serious adverse health consequences or death, unless you document that another approach provides adequate assurances.
  • Corrective actions and reevaluation (21 CFR 1.508 and § 1.505(c)). If a supplier is not meeting the applicable food-safety standard, take prompt, documented corrective action, which can include discontinuing use of the supplier. Reevaluate the food and the supplier promptly when you learn new information, and at least every three years if you have not already done so.
  • Importer identification, a qualified individual, and records. At entry, 21 CFR 1.509 requires the FSVP importer’s name, electronic mail address, and a unique facility identifier recognized by FDA for each line entry. FDA has recognized the DUNS number as an acceptable identifier. A qualified individual must develop the FSVP and perform the required activities (21 CFR 1.503). Under 21 CFR 1.510, records must be signed and dated, kept legible, and made promptly available to FDA, and generally retained for at least two years.

Common mistakes

The problems in this warning letter are not unusual. Common ones include:

  • Treating a generic FSVP SOP, or a consultant’s template, as a completed program for every food and supplier you import.
  • Building FSVPs for products you no longer import, while current products have no program.
  • Hiring a consultant, or signing a service agreement, and assuming the regulatory obligation has been met.
  • Having a written procedure, but no records that analyses, evaluations, approvals, or verification activities were actually performed.
  • Failing to identify the FSVP importer correctly at entry, including the unique facility identifier.
  • Not reevaluating a supplier when new information appears, such as a warning letter, an import alert, or a food-safety complaint.
  • Responding to FDA with a plan to create an FSVP, rather than with the FSVP and the implementation records the Agency asked for.

If you have received a Form FDA 483a or a warning letter

FDA’s letter in this case asked for a written response within 15 working days, with documentation that would help the Agency evaluate the corrections, such as a copy of the FSVP and records showing it has been implemented. If all corrections cannot be finished in that time, the letter asks the firm to explain the delay and state when the remaining work will be completed.

Start with an inventory of every food and foreign supplier you currently import. A qualified individual should then develop, document, and implement an FSVP for each combination that needs one. Send FDA the actual documents and implementation records, not only a statement that you have retained help. If you need more time, say so clearly and give a realistic date.

FSPCA FSVP training and consulting with BQUALI

If you are responsible for an FSVP, official training is one practical way to build the knowledge a qualified individual needs. BQUALI delivers the FSPCA Foreign Supplier Verification Programs course as a live, virtual, instructor-led class, taught by an FSPCA Lead Instructor. Upon attending the entire program, participants receive an official certificate issued by the Association of Food and Drug Officials (AFDO).

Upcoming live virtual sessions include December 16–17, 2026, and February 16–17, 2027, with additional dates scheduled through 2027. The fee starts from $600 and includes the Participant Manual, the Exercise Workbook, and the certificate. See the full schedule and register on the FSVP training page.

If you need help building or reviewing an FSVP, rather than training alone, see BQUALI’s auditing and consulting page, or contact us at info@bquali.com.

Other upcoming courses

A note from the author

An FSVP is not a binder you buy, and it is not a consultant’s name on a contract. It is a food- and supplier-specific program that you develop, maintain, and follow, with records you can show FDA. If you want help getting there, you are welcome to join a live virtual FSVP session or to ask us about consulting support.

Dr. Maxime Ndayizeye is an FSPCA Lead Instructor and the founder of BQUALI, a food-safety training, auditing, and consulting firm serving manufacturers and importers in the United States and Canada.

Sources

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *